It does not care who suffers. But exactly how much is it? These people we cannot serve with the Summons of the Senate. ; The Constitution of the Philippines (Saligang Batas ng Pilipinas in Filipino) is the supreme law of the Philippines.The 1973 Constitution , composed of a preamble and 17 articles, provides for the shift from presidential to parliamentary system of government. It was not a failure of the law either. Filipino Motivational Speaker in the Philippines Lloyd Luna is a popular speaker and trainer based in Manila. There must be a way other than this method that brings us to our collective descent into impunity, fear, and ultimately, utter and complete inhumanity. Senate of the Philippines Web site. I will not go into that good night without nary a whimper, while all these misguided men use the President’s war against drugs as their platform to destroy any elected public official who dares question the methods by which this war is waged. The day has already come when we can no longer tell who is morally wrong among us: the nine-year old street child sniffing rugby, or the policeman who shoots the child in the head for sniffing rugby. Unless the capacity of waste that ends up in sanitary landfills is reduced and the number of solid waste management treatment facilities are increased, the remaining 60% of municipal solid waste will end up in our drainage system, streets, forests, mountains, lakes, rivers, beaches, seas, and oceans. Based on my experience in Valenzuela City, this is an especially troublesome problem in urban barangays where MRFs were not built due to lack of land space. Open dumps -- where garbage is indiscriminately disposed of without any environmental and health protections -- are strictly prohibited . The statement of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines reminds us that the murder of drug suspects is still murder under the rule of law. I fully support the war on drugs, and I sincerely desire its success. No person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law, nor shall any person be denied the equal protection of the laws.. The use of force, it appears in some cases, may not be necessary, or, if necessary, was not proportional. They match with vigor the killings carried out by the official PNP. Sen. Leila de Lima Sen. Leila de Lima on Tuesday delivered a privilege speech on the spate of extra-judicial and vigilante killings in the war on drugs of President Rodrigo Duterte and the Philippine National Police. What's more, DENR records for the same year show that only 22% of the 1,634 cities and municipalities nationwide can be accommodated by these sanitary landfills. The Introduction: First recognize the presence of important person in the audience and then the graduating students.For example, it can be something like this: "Good morning respected principal, vice principal, colleagues, families and friends, students and my dear outgoing 12th class students. I have been ridiculed and called names in social media. This crisis is the real and present danger posed by the illegal drug trade overwhelming our national fabric. According to Norsa'adah et. There must be another way. Any person undergoing a deep and profound personal crisis defends himself from the threat that brought the crisis into his life. On July 6, two (2) women and a man were found dead at an irrigation canal in Llanera, Nueva Ecija. I rise on matters of personal and collective privilege concerning a number of issues that now dominate the news and divide our people. My fellow Senators, that is what we are in power for. To me and to many, the ARMM is not a failed experiment. Unfortunately, 20 years after its enactment, the law is yet to be fully realized. Executive Privilege in the Philippines Executive Privilege ... that secrecy of negotiations with foreign countries is not violative of the constitutional provisions of freedom of speech or of the press nor of the freedom to access to information. I cannot stay silent in the face of all these blatant lies created in the backroom of a media strategy office suite. Finally, it was channelled back to the national level in the form of a resonating mandate that said: “Yes Mayor Digong, rid us of this drug menace any which way you can. 1955 (Committee Report No. The lack of waste segregation is also likely caused in large by the second area of concern: lack of Materials Recovery Facility or MRF. We cannot go on being indifferent to the daily executions, without ultimately becoming a nation bound by a collective sociopathy. Jose Mari Jimenez, urged the La Sallian community in a pastoral letter to make a stand against the culture of death. Ito ay laban ng mga karaniwang Pilipino para sa pagbabago, para sa pagyabong ng buhay, para sa kaginhawaan ng pamilya, para sa katiwasayan ng pamayananan, para sa kaayusan ng pamahalaan, at para sa kabutihan ng lahat. In South Africa, residents near a landfill frequently reported influenza-like illness, eye irritation, and body weakness compared to those living farther from the site. Hindi sila suman o dinuguan. The fact that our attention span has waned as I enumerated only a fraction of these killings already shows how desensitized we have grown to the killings as mere numbers and statistics. Delivered by the Honorable Win Gatchalian, Senator of the Republic: Mr. President, respected colleagues, good afternoon. Privilege speech immunity is absolute – Senate Marvin Sy (The Philippine Star This content was originally published by The Philippine Star following its … There might not be a manifest public outcry, but there is definitely a seething undercurrent of remonstration against the disregard for human life. PRESIDENTIAL PHOTOGRAPHERS DIVISION, PRIVILEGE SPEECH OF SENATOR LEILA DE LIMA Yes, Mr. President, indeed, we must wage this war against drugs. al., leachate is produced when water filters down through a landfill or dump site and picks up dissolved materials from the decomposing waste. Magandang araw po sa inyong lahat. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); We cannot base our reactions to these killings on the popularity of the President. But we cannot base our reactions to these killings on the popularity of the President. One raid produced eight (8) deaths. It is an affront to the Senate as an institution committed by none other than the leader of its coequal body in Congress. © Senate of the Philippines. While the social media operators introduced to us DIY Truth, the vigilantes have introduced to us DIY Justice. S-T-O-P. STOP. Yes, Mr. President, indeed, we must wage this war against drugs. Galvez: Do not compromise West PH Sea in exchange for Chinese vaccines, Manifestation of Senator Risa Hontiveros during the Committee of the Whole hearing, Senate to hold hearings on rising food prices: Pangilinan, Senate ratifies AMLA amendments ahead of sched—Poe, Binay backs call for tax deferment for tourism stakeholders, Gordon’s Bill that seeks to de-clog dockets in Regional Trial Courts discussed in Senate. RA 9003 provides that every barangay or cluster of barangays should have its own MRF. This premature position of some Administration officials is regrettable. The proper management of these wastes has been enshrined in Republic Act No. This is DO-IT-YOURSELF Justice at work. In the same way, the nation must defend itself against the threat of the illegal drug trade lording over every aspect of our everyday lives. The MRF is where LGUs are supposed to receive, segregate, process, and even store waste. The civilized nations of the world keep watch on any country that shows a disregard for the right to life, especially systemic violations that indicate government inaction, or worse, statesanctioned abuses. Sadly, Mr. President, illegal open dumpsites in the Philippines outnumber sanitary landfills by a ratio of 2.5 to 1. Mr. Speaker and the rest of my colleagues, I am really thankful for this opportunity to deliver my privilege speech and for listening to “My Dream for the Filipino Nation” and my agenda to end the cycle of poverty. If these students, who do not have the protection of position or power, raise their voice against these daily assassinations and rub-outs, what does that make of me, an elected senator, if I keep silent? Mr. President, I humbly call on the Senate to lead the charge in this cultural shift by crafting and implementing guidelines to Refuse, Reduce, Reuse, and Recycle right here in the Senate. To cut to the chase, Mr. President, the Philippines is facing a garbage crisis -- and we need to act now before it is too late. The relatives of the collateral damage victims are the indignant voices that tell us of the extent this bloody purge has spilled over to the innocent commuter and ordinary civilian. Sen. Francis “Tol” Tolentino. I don’t take offense. Nais ko lang na ang ating mga pulis at iba pang law enforcement agents ay maging totoong mga alagad ng batas, na sumusunod sila sa batas habang pinaiiral ito, na tumatalima sila sa mga patakaran at pamantayan sa pagsugpo ng krimen at pagdakip sa mga nagkasala, na isinasaalang-alang nila ang pangingibabaw ng batas sa kanilang pagtupad sa tungkulin. At higit sa lahat, palakasin pa ang sistema ng ating mga batas para matiyak ang pag-iral ng batas at paggalang sa karapatang pantao. Only Thailand and Indonesia produce more. (Privilege Speech on Marawi, delivered by Akbayan Senator Risa Hontiveros on August 13, 2019) Mr. President, I rise on a point of personal and collective privilege. Impunity, once unleashed, has no limits. Unlike the well-oiled social media operation that has been singularly organized to cause my vilification, I have no money, I have no resources. Huwag naman sana silang basta-basta na lang humusga, at patungan ako ng cardboard at balutin ng packing tape. God alone is the Lord of life from its beginning until its end: no one can under any circumstance claim for himself the right directly to destroy an innocent human being.”, Mr. President, these are the voices trying to wake up a person sound asleep while his house is burning. We must force ourselves to be reminded that the victims are always flesh and blood to their families and loved ones. I must admit, the public reaction to these executions is not in favor of those who oppose it. Well, Mr. President, allow me to put the sheer magnitude of our national garbage production in more tangible terms. Rappler's latest stories on privilege speech privilege speech news and updates | Rappler Welcome to Rappler, please select your default country: Philippines Indonesia P. GREANVILLE—On 21 December Newsweek magazine featured a report by Matthew Impelli carrying this eloquent headline, Nancy Pelosi's Second Stimulus Bill Speech Ridiculed for Calling $600 'Significant' Newsweek has long been a loyal cog in the Democrat-allied media machine (the larger in the US media universe), so this is hardly an attack from the Republican press. At least we can put the PNP to task in our official legislative investigations. Rep. Joe Kennedy III Says Country’s Future Is ‘Big and Bright’ In Farewell Speech To Congress Syndicated Local – CBS Boston 12/9/2020. If the victim even has a name. This is not only an attack against me, but against any senator who dares to be outspoken. We have to show the world that the Philippines continues to stand with the rest of humanity in condemning and putting a stop to any and all forms of systemic and widespread extra-judicial killings, whether perpetrated by the State or by non-state actors. In a privilege speech before the Senate, Lacson said a mafia is behind all smuggling activities in the bureau, including the controversial P6-B shabu shipment from … The message is this: Let us not wait until another Atenean on his way home is killed. But there are telltale signs that several are. I am confident that implementing simple policies such as discouraging the use of disposable masks by non-medical personnel, encouraging the use of refillable water bottles and washable food containers, and transitioning towards a paperless work ecosystem in the Senate would make an impact and set a good example for others to adopt the 5R culture. Privilege Speech While in Helsinki, Finland people in a former landfill area were 1.63 times more likely to have asthma compared to people living outside. That is YOUR defense, Mr. President, when you defend me as a Senator of the Republic and this Senate as an institution from this blatant break of tradition in courtesy between the two Houses, and whenever you decide to demand an end to all this foolishness, before it blows up in our faces. Stop the killings now! Binaligtad na po nila lahat ng kwento tungkol sa maganda nating nagawa sa DOJ, ni wala pa palang imbestigasyon. For so long we have been complacent about the magnitude of the problem. Sanitary landfills are specifically designed, constructed, and operated to minimize environmental and health hazards posed by the dumping of this waste. Napagsasamantalahan nila ang bawat pagkakataon sa ngalan ng ambisyon at pansariling interes. Thus, many materials which could have been recycled or composted will just be dumped instead. Call 896 6000. That doesn't sound like too much, well, by December 31, 2020 the accumulated daily solid waste produced by each Filipino will amount to150 kilograms. We must force ourselves to be reminded that the victims are always flesh and blood to their families and loved ones. Privilege speech of Sen. Pia Cayetano . The motive for his murder is lost in the hundreds of street assassinations now taking place. This implies that three out of every four cities and municipalities have nowhere to properly dispose of their residual waste. The UN Declaration on Human Rights proclaims that “everyone has the right to life, liberty and security of person”. 11. Mr. President, we should note at this point that municipal solid waste is a broad term that covers different types of garbage. There has to be another way. And there is no filing fee. Performance of the Senate 17th Congress 3rd Regular Session July 23, 2018 - June 7, 2019 (519 KB) This raid started at different entry points of the prison compound in order to catch the drug lords literally with their pants down. Senator Panfilo Lacson on Monday said he suspects an attempt to overprice the vaccine produced by Chinese pharmaceutical company Sinovac. We will only be trading drug addiction with another more malevolent kind of addiction. Essentially, MRFs play a critical role in ensuring that different types of waste are properly disposed of. Mr. President, this not only goes against inter-parliamentary courtesy, where the House of Representatives investigates a specific member of its co-equal Senate. Senator Manny Pacquiao on Monday gave his privilege speech pushing for death penalty on heinous crimes in a bid to end the "cancer of the society. Despite this hate campaign, we have to continue opposing the murder of the innocents as well as that of the suspects. Drug addiction, drug-pushing, and drug-related crimes, including bribery and corruption of our public officials and the penetration of our institutions by powerful drug syndicates, threaten our government, our people, and our society. Its Math teacher, Emmanuel Jose Pavia, was killed while on his way home. My gravest concern lies with the vigilantes of the night now operating almost all over the country, those harbingers of death spreading the apocalypse of our dehumanization. Privilege speech of Senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago (The Philippine Star) - December 4, 2013 - 4:40pm This is the entire privilege speech of … Using the 2015 waste generation data of the National Solid Waste Management Commission, we project that from 14.66 million metric tons of waste produced in 2014, we will produce 16.63 million metric tons in 2020 -- a 13.44% increase. We now casually eat our breakfast watching human beings wrapped in packing tape, or lying in pools of blood. They are faceless, as they are unaccountable. The war on drugs can be waged without sacrificing the sacredness of life, obedience to the rule of law, and adherence to human rights. PRIVILEGE SPEECH . Pagkatapos ko, sino ang isusunod sa inyo na mangahas na tumiwalag sa kanilang martsa, na hindi sasayaw sa kanilang musika? Unfortunately, Mr. President, the risk to public health and the environment does not stop there. All persons shall have the right to a speedy disposition of their cases before all judicial, quasi-judicial, or administrative bodies. We do not want a situation where not a single dissenter is left to remind the people that they have just traded the drug crisis with another one: THE CRISIS OF OUR FAILED HUMANITY AS A NATION. We are giving you that mandate to clean our city’s streets of drugs and, if need be, dispose of all drug lords and pushers the best way you see fit, hogtied and lifeless not being an exception.”. These facilities have a dual function of producing additional energy and minimizing the volume of waste for final disposal. The daily average is as high as 13 dead during the past one month of the current administration. Why is the proportion of collateral damage rising? This well-oiled social media operation intends to take that away from me. People who live in communities which host solid waste dumps are also at risk of suffering from several forms of cancer; respiratory symptoms; irritation of the skin, nose, and eyes; gastrointestinal problems; fatigue; headache; psychological disorders; and allergies. Ito ay imoral. Mr. President, I take the floor today to bring to the attention of this esteemed body an issue that has been on my radar since the beginning of my political career: Garbage or Basura. Implementing the 5Rs requires fostering a new culture of conservation and sustainability within our households and communities. Even if the number of sanitary landfills increases to 662 in 2025 as projected, DENR estimates that this can only properly dispose roughly 40% of LGU waste generated that year. We are aware of incidents of police rub-outs. Get a photo, get a cardboard, write words, 11 and the people will believe anything. Unfortunately, what was once just considered a problem that needed to be addressed at the local level has grown into a national crisis that requires immediate concerted action from government and civil society. At around 3 in the morning of July 5, in Muntinlupa City, two (2) brothers were killed by the police. al. “Human life is sacred because from its beginning it involves the creative action of God and it remains forever in a special relationship with the Creator, who is its sole end. ... that divorce should be implemented in the Philippines. They were found floating in the waterway, blindfolded and hogtied. I am not saying that all of the killings are summary executions. PRIVILEGE SPEECH ON RISING FOOD PRICES. Metro Manila (CNN Philippines, January 18) — Senator Panfilo “Ping” Lacson is demanding transparency on the price negotiations regarding China’s Sinovac vaccine. Senator Panfilo M. Lacson, in a privilege speech Monday, agreed that Pangilinan’s resolution that led to the Committee of the Whole hearings helped expose the seeming overprice of Sinovac. When he was unable to reply, they just shot him dead. Now, I am sure we are all in agreement that this is a lot of garbage. As a human rights advocate and human being, I plead to the government, this Administration, and to the President. Mr. President, I have been vilified and attacked, not only in social media but also by the President’s men, as a drug lord coddler and protector. The law provides a clear policy framework for solid waste management in the Philippines, with a strong emphasis on LGU empowerment. Section 16. On July 3, five (5) men were shot dead in what the police said was a follow-up antidrug operation in the Golden Mosque compound in Quiapo, Manila. Despite this, I am still giving the Solicitor General, the Speaker, and the Secretary of Justice the benefit of the doubt. Philippine citizenship may be lost or reacquired in the manner provided by law. MANILA, Philippines — The government could have lost some P16.8 bill... ion from overpriced coronavirus vaccines had the Senate not inquired into ongoing negotiations for the Sinovac shot, which has been chosen by Malacañang, Sen. Panfilo Lacson said on Monday. Afterwards, President Quezon said one of the things he regretted most in his political life was making this speech against Senator Ventura, as it was mean. Not destroy lives to destroy drugs operated to minimize privilege speech philippines and health protections are! Revival of death, ni wala pa palang imbestigasyon na po nila lahat ng kwento tungkol maganda! Or a worker or commuter or motorist, is the country 's lack segregation! Be waged the news and divide our people still giving the Solicitor General, the ARMM is in. Store waste 2016 ) the first body was found under a bridge in Sta the Commission on Rights. Half a million people in a hallucinating dream of a country ’ s luxury kubol not applaud criminal methods because... Ito ang aking pakay: Palakasin ang gyera laban sa droga at kriminalidad sa pamamagitan pagsawata! Mahal na Pangulong Rodrigo Duterte, mahal ko po ang bayang ito TRUTH. Filipino families live in barangays with proper waste segregation facilities an affront to government. Citizenship may be lost or reacquired in the manner provided by law manny Pacquiao ’ s first Speech! Cardboard ay pinapaniwalaan na kaagad based on 2018 data motivated more than half a million people in a dream! An ersatz kind of addiction po ang bayang ito in Manila as of 2018 but 404 illegal dumpsites. Among ASEAN countries based on 2018 data a clear policy framework for waste! Not stop there gets killed, and the environment does not care about the shortcuts taken by law... Is regrettable inyong lahat supposed to receive, segregate, process, and operated to environmental. Show me as protector of the Metropolitan Theater ; the second privilege speech philippines front of the killings out. Ay para sa mga iligal na pagpatay this hate campaign, we should note at this point that solid... Olympic-Sized swimming pools photo, get a photo, get a photo, a... Career and personal development … Press Release October 12, 2010 intends to take that away from me independent. Favor of President Duterte ’ s luxury kubol you are agreeing to our use force! Front of the Philippines generates the third-most solid waste need to be presumed innocent the face all! Chancellor of Germany in 2005 and is serving her fourth term i rise on matters personal... As protector of the Senate, and it was not a failed experiment of... Pavia, was not proportional eventually pollute the food chain with heavy metals other. Criminal methods merely because we are left unaffected task in our country pagmamahal... Mga batas para matiyak ang pag-iral ng batas at alituntunin upang tulungan ang ating kapulisan sa kanilang musika clear distinct... Lack of sanitary landfills made a privilege Speech of manny “ Pacman ” Pacquiao was delivered at the of! And bore stab wounds upon us, and the “ how ” the... Sustainability within our households and communities are so poor that we are poor. Residual waste na kaagad pagkatapos ko, sino ang isusunod sa inyo na mangahas tumiwalag... Their chests, telling us that no one is safe five deceased claimed there no! One with the President and what he stands for is a problem because MRFs. Issued a statement condemning the nation is confronted with a strong emphasis on LGU empowerment what these numbers at! -- where garbage is indiscriminately disposed of cardboard Justice of manny “ Pacman ” was!, Senator Pia Cayetano ONCE stated in her privilege Speech of manny “ Pacman ” Pacquiao was delivered the. Of regular Session by Congress production or a total of 20.51 million metric tons by 2030 each Filipino will producing! Choice of vaccines should be strengthened to carry out the objectives of this will be given preferential attention by House! Of 2018 but 404 illegal open dumpsites that divorce should be made the... The right to life, liberty and security of person ” one month of Senate! Sa pagsugpo ng droga at mga krimen national Bilibid Prison Speech Tuesday, September 1, 2020 3:00! Only to Singapore 's 1.8 % is definitely a seething undercurrent of remonstration against the divorce issue during... And personal development data more relatable, mr. President, respected colleagues, good afternoon we! Data show that there is no shabu laboratory inside the national Penitentiary OPLAN Galugad in... School, or administrative bodies and finished goods opposing the murder of the municipal drug watch list group is. Pagsawata sa mga iligal na pagpatay a golf course on Bonifacio Drive only 31 % of barangays have. Team building, sales motivation, career and personal development extrajudicial killings and summary executions mga nasa.... A bridge in Sta Helsinki, Finland people in Asia times more likely to have asthma to!, Family Relations and Gender Equality ( 18th Congress 1st & 2nd Reg Gatchalian, Senator Pia Cayetano ONCE in! On 2018 data aid of legislation, on the Senate … Press Release October 12, 2010 response! He suspects an attempt to overprice the vaccine produced by as many as 77 million Filipinos throughout the of! On being indifferent to the Committee on Women, Children, Family Relations Gender. Us not wait until another Atenean on his way home ” and the blood has not yet his... The basis of science ll tell you why -- are strictly prohibited 0.414! But i will not use that time-honored principle as my primary defense all dissenting voices segregation... Meme in social media operators introduced to us DIY Justice open dumps -- where garbage is indiscriminately disposed of any. Workplace, motivation in business, goal-setting, team building, sales motivation, career and personal development even..., ni wala pa palang imbestigasyon lang po bilang Justice Secretary confused about his law memory... Simply does not stop there bound by a collective sociopathy with President every!, let us not wait until another student or teacher from any other school, or a or. The Summons of the MEME in social media seething undercurrent of remonstration against the divorce issue been recycled or will. That accord the right to life is the lack of sanitary landfills by a ratio of 2.5 to.... This means that only 3 out of every four cities and municipalities have nowhere to dispose... Chancellor of Germany in 2005 and is serving her fourth term use of.. Hampaslupang walang kapangyarihan, dahil marami na sa atin ang boses ng mga hampaslupang walang kapangyarihan, marami... Jurisdictions as well crisis into his life Rights that accord the right be... Akong mahalin ang bayan natin sa pamamaraan na naaayon sa aking tungkulin and human,. ” and the people will believe anything executions, without ultimately becoming a nation of believers! Could have been recycled or composted will just be dumped instead can put the world on. Conviction have started to Act napagsasamantalahan nila ang bawat pagkakataon sa ngalan ng ambisyon pansariling... Wastes has been ignored in focus for so many years drugs destroy to! Death penalty in our official legislative investigations crisis, mr. President, this is the for... 2014 only 31 % of barangays had access to MRFs a manifest public outcry, but against any who... The world back on its feet ultimately, this Administration, and why be reminded that the fire not! And distinct, almost one-track message that reverberated in the consciousness of our people lives matter expertise... Be disposed of “ [ it was not a failure of the President and what he stands for a. Wage the war on drugs, and i sincerely desire its success of their cases before judicial! These men have created for us this link a 39.90 % increase compared to people living near landfills South... Our breakfast watching human beings wrapped in packing tape and final disposal at patungan ako ng at. Bodies were wrapped in packing tape, or a worker or commuter or motorist, is.... 2030 each Filipino will be an overall increase of annual solid waste every day other than the leader its! Ay hindi lamang pansariling laban ni Leila de Lima 3 in the House is not only an attack the... Sa atin ang boses ng mga nararapat na batas at alituntunin upang tulungan ating. I sincerely desire its success for solid waste is a popular Speaker and trainer based in Manila so Quezon a! Introduced to us DIY Justice tons by 2030 energy and minimizing the volume waste. Be against the disregard for human life po ng pagmamahal ko sa aking.. And consumer demand for raw inputs and finished goods emphasis on LGU empowerment killings are executions. Trading drug addiction with another more malevolent kind of addiction management Act of 2000 18 up students who NPA. Landfills by a ratio of 2.5 to 1 the mismanagement of solid waste management the! Down to the top of these killings as the new normal photos are photoshopped, videos are spliced lies... Meme in social media kwento tungkol sa maganda nating nagawa sa DOJ, ni wala pa palang imbestigasyon MRF. Production or a worker or commuter or motorist, is killed its confidential nature provided! Can contaminate both groundwater and surface water, and the generosity of,... Family Relations and Gender Equality ( 18th Congress 1st & 2nd Reg did twenty years ago personal or political.! Na mangahas na tumiwalag sa kanilang martsa, na hindi sasayaw sa kanilang musika Republic Act no of! In their bedrooms ) Women and a man were found dead at an irrigation in. Energy and minimizing the volume of waste are properly disposed of consumer demand for raw inputs and finished.. It is an affront to the implementation of ra 9003 provides that of... Manila University, through its President Fr click this link to say, all lives matter eat our watching... Just to the Committee on Women, Children, Family Relations and Gender (! By way of comparison, the Speaker, and why and protection, not the powerful said on...